https://www.kusanaginosya.com/SHOP/496.html
Just came across this blade that I thought had a ton of historical context!
Unju naginata naoshi katana
Kiritsuke-mei stating it was a possession of the famed warlord Kato Kiyomasa
Hon'ami Nisshu origami + sayagaki
Showa 23 "daimyo" torokusho
Nobuyoshi 信賀 apparently was a early name of Dotanuki Masakuni
Asking price might be reasonable if this was papered...Dotanuki seem to be even more in demand in recent years
I agree completely. But looking at this blade, its attribution and shinsa session I still don't think it is hugely underpriced, around a third of the price for a daito Jūto by upper tier Tegai of this quality.
Ofc that is only my opinion
I think for most collectors disregarding older papers or 'buy the sword not the paper' is really only feasible for a certain level/price of sword. Say for a run-of-the-mill shinto wakizashi it may not feasible to send to a shinsa given that the rise in value would not be substantial enough.
However, if you are the market to buy or sell items say on the level of Darcy's stock then it would be imperative to get up-to-date papers
- as a seller it would mean you could ask for substantially higher sales prices
- Potential buyers will take you seriously. Most buyers would be uncomfortable in taking a punt on a high-price mumei blade with old papers.
Obviously the price threshold would be different for everyone but once a blade reaches a certain value most collectors would probably want the piece of mind of a recognised paper imo
Yep toko taikan corroborates this.
It says the Smith name was Sawahara Noboru, han-shi of Shirakawa domain, student of Naotane
Worked from Bunka to Ansei. Worked in Soshu-den but also has suguha works.
IMHO I think the requirements of tanto Signed+dated+koshirae+papered all <250,000 Yen is a pretty tall order even in the current market
good luck
edit: Closest one I found - http://nihontou.jp/choice03/toukenkobugu/tantou/131/00.html
Dated Meiji 2, Hozon, koshirae but 300,000 Yen