I'd like to share an observation that has been puzzling me, and perhaps some of you may be able to shed light on this:
I've noticed that some blades appear to have asymmetrically carved hi.
Now I may perhaps be a bit peculiar in this regard, but to be honest, this greatly upsets my sense of aesthetics.
Just to avoid misunderstandings, I'm not talking about cases where the asymmetry is clearly intentional (e.g., bohi on one side, futasuji-hi on the other, like this one). I am referring to examples where the length of the bohi differs by just a few millimetres, like in the two images attached below [found on aoijapan.jp]. Both of these blades were attributed to well-regarded koto makers and designated juyo token, so they were evidently recognised as high-quality items.
Given the precision and attention to detail that is normally associated with nihonto-related crafts, this sort of seemingly accidental asymmetry strikes me as odd.
Is it just sloppy workmanship of whoever carved the hi, possibly indicative of ato-bori, or a poor polishing job? Might this even be intended for functional reasons (balance)?
And would this be considered a flaw and affect the value of the blade? It certainly does to me... Or do people think this gives the blade a sort of rustic charm?
Is there something obvious I'm missing here?