Jump to content

David Flynn

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2,869

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    6

 Content Type 

Everything posted by David Flynn

  1. David Flynn
    A very warm welcome to our newest members.
  2. David Flynn
    Where are they?
  3. David Flynn
    If it's not a strain on your finances, why not?
  4. David Flynn
    Star stamp means the this is a RJT (Rikugun Jumei Tosho) and the sword is an military commissioned Gendaito. The Seki stamp means, the sword has come through the Seki arsenal and is probably non tradionaly made. Lack of stamps, usually means a privately commissioned sword..
  5. David Flynn
    Wow comparing all on two swords! I personally don't care where a sword is made, as long as it's good.
  6. David Flynn
    Welcome Kunitaro, I hope you find the forum interesting.
  7. David Flynn
    Again Chris, I will have to dissagree with you. I have quite a few Seki blades, I would definately say a better than most Yasukuni blades. Saying this though, isn't it all proportional? A good blade, made by any smith, is a good blade.
  8. David Flynn
    I actually believe, the decline in memberships, for Sword Socs. is the amount of information available on the internet. This forum is a perfect example.
  9. David Flynn
    Well as yet, there has been no reply.
  10. David Flynn
    Brian, these don't look like " Expat" swords, they look like high class Chinese copies. We saw an example of these at the Sydney Shinsa, last year. They look Japanese, but just, not quite right.
  11. David Flynn
    Well, myself and another member of this board discussed this issue. We both thought it very likely that they were chinese. However, just going by photos. Both of us decided to use discretion and keep it to ourselves.
  12. David Flynn
    If people put things up for sale, why shouldn't one be allowed to ask questions and give opinions? Don't we ask our friends opinions?
  13. David Flynn
    So sellers should be protected, but not buyers?
  14. David Flynn
    I know that ebay is "Fair Game," though surely one must have some integrity when selling on a large scale. Could this just be naivety, on the part of the seller? Here is a wonderful lesson for beginners. This was only picked up by experience looking at many, many swords, over quite a while.
  15. David Flynn
    Is it just me, or is there a distinct similarity between these swords? http://www.ebay.com/itm/140835084693?ss ... 1423.l2649 http://www.ebay.com/itm/Japanese-Samura ... 1e71994191 http://www.ebay.com/itm/Japanese-Samura ... 1e71992529 http://www.ebay.com/itm/Japanese-Samura ... 1e7199163e
  16. David Flynn
    Stu, the Star Stamp means, it was made by a Rikugun Jumei Tosho, and is a Geandaito.
  17. David Flynn
    looks like an oil tempered showato.
  18. David Flynn
    Hi Chris, sorry for taking so long to get back. Yes, it's Amazu Masakiyo from Shimane. I was unable to find what you had previously written, so any information, would be appreciated.
  19. David Flynn
    I'm trying to find information, of the Gendai Smith, Masakiyo. A friend of mine showed me a sword by Masakiyo and asked my opinion. I personally thought it quite a good sword. However, neither of us, have been able to find anything, on him. If anyone could help, it would be most appreciated.
  20. David Flynn
    I'm principally a Gendai Collector. I don't care which school they come from, as long as they are well made. I also have a couple of Shin Shinto pieces which are very good ( they virtually fell into my lap). My criteria is, 1. Value. Is the sword worth the asking price ( This, unfortunately only comes with experience)? 2. Do I like it? 3. Am I able to live with it, as it is? 4. Almost forgot this one. Is it Gimei. Yes there are definitely Gimei Gendaito.
  21. David Flynn
    Welcome Steve.
  22. David Flynn
    Brian, this sword has faults. These faults may and probably will become worse, with a polish. Next, have the Mei (signature) fully checked out, to make sure it is Genuine. As you like this sword, leave it as it is for a while, whilst you are on your learning curb. With more Knowledge, you may eventually change your mind and save some money.
  23. David Flynn
    Truly Bogus!
  24. David Flynn
    May I ask, what is it about them, you actually like?
  25. David Flynn

    Gassan

    David Flynn replied to Lindus's topic in Nihonto

    Information and value, of Gendaito have risen dramatically, in the last 20yrs. If one remembers Mishina Kenji's forward, in the Yasukuni shrine sword book, he had never considered the quality of these blades until he polished one. As we all now know, these sword are highly desirous.
×
×
  • Create New...