Spartancrest

Yes, sorry the only image I had was taken at an angle. I like the way the sukashi is outlined in both cases it really shows the design off better.

Grev I am still looking - this is something similar I have seen a few of - but still not close enough. described as "Kyoshoami" twigs and chrysanthemums.

This one is described as "Powerful Shachi figure" - he looks rather smug or condescending. https://www.jauce.com/auction/c1070365266 The ura is rather smooth looking and I would not be surprised if it were cast.

Too bright?

Great Ford - and no water damage and fewer creases - I might have a play with this image and bring it out a bit more. Mulberry paper is a little dark for me!

Piers, here is the list according to Robinson. Sorry it is not a PDF.

Work this one out if you can - the original print is in the Metropolitan Museum of Art - listed as under copyright restriction on one link and Public domain on another? What happens can you be half sued? https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/855670 - can't use "rights restricted" https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/56927 - can use public domain. Perhaps someone should let them know - not me!

Okan, I took the liberty some time back to "clean the image" as much as possible - boy I wish they had not folded the original! There is a plate in the back of B. W. Robinsons book.

I am not a sword collector but that is very good detective work Thomas. I wonder if Lisa is still waiting on this information? You might try a PM and let her know.

Darrel I have been talking to the Walters Art Museum for a short while, they have been very helpful with supplying images and information on a book I am about to release on their collection - specifically their tsuba collection. The person to contact is Laura Seitter lseitter@thewalters.org The museum sometimes takes a day to answer any enquiry but that is complicated by the time zone differences for me. Give it a try I am sure she will put you through to any relevant curator. Laura Seitter (she/her) Imaging and Rights Coordinator (410) 547-9000 ext. 245

Thanks Colin - I am of the same opinion, as the chisel used for the signatures is very much thicker on one than the other. There is a big difference in the quality of the 'worm eaten rim' and I would have thought the Wakizashi would have the more 'showy' display. The signatures also translate slightly differently - not what you would expect if they were made at the same time? [Signature and Place] 越前府住　廣次作; [Transliteration] Echizen fu jû/Hirotsugu saku; [Translation] Residing in Echizen (province)/made by Hirotsugu [Transcription] 越前府住　春田廣次; [Transliteration] Echizen fu jû/Haruta Hirotsugu; [Translation] Residing in Echizen (province)/Haruta Hirotsugu

I am doing some research on a "pair" of tsuba, but the way the mei has been cut strikes me as very odd in comparing the two. Both these guards are from the Walters Art Museum and are described as a pair - what opinions would you offer? The guard on the left is 77 mm and the one on the right 65 mm in Diam. Thanks in advance.

Richard, could the rim represent stylised clouds perhaps? At least it would fit in with the flying birds.

David, I think the thickened rim is just a design element framing the bamboo, it isn't carried through on the ura or the bottom of the guard as a Dote-mimi would be. Pretty sure it isn't 管耳 Kan-mimi - Thicker rounder raised rims. (Thicker and rounder than Dote-mimi )

Jean is KARAHANA OR KARABANA the right word you are looking for? "Chinese Flower" [most have five petals but as a kamon some have four.] Karabana (or karahana) design on Japanese printed fabric featuring mon heraldic crests Also seen as a squared off version. The actual flower “Four-petalled” leaves attached to the persimmon

David I just found what is missing from that patch at the bottom omote side of your guard - an inlay of a bird. Three of a kind must have been a popular design, likely others out there. No further along with who made it or when - sorry. http://ancientpoint.com/inf/13134-large_tsuba___bird__bamboo___mokko_style_tasteful_86mm_box.html Popular design indeed - if they like it enough to make cast copies! https://www.jauce.com/auction/b1040148320

A super rusty one makes five! https://www.jauce.com/auction/f1068140619

Okan - not so fresh [just a better image. ] Book - Serious Suriage Damage? [your idea] Damnedest Cut! or how about "Leave the bloody things alone!"

Luca, you would make a good detective! Colin, "Synchronicity" [it happens to me all the time. ] The double even has those "dimples"(?) on the semicircular side panels - no idea what they represent?

Or three? This one with inlay! https://www.jauce.com/auction/t1067947541 - Uniique NOT.

Well I found the original shape of that cherry branch one. There are some slight differences with the decoration so it is unlikely they are cast. Might make a "forced" daisho? https://www.jauce.com/auction/d1067356293 https://www.jauce.com/auction/h1056992179

I have seen many "everyday" objects with tsuba designs,- trivets, beltbuckles, coasters, cake molds/moulds and candlesticks most are made of course in Japan. These Zippo lighters are branded "Made in USA" It seems a strange subject for a firelighter. https://www.jauce.com/user/nudmr48674?search=tsuba https://jp.mercari.com/item/m64078098798 https://jp.mercari.com/item/m93002899452 No great shakes as far as design or execution but hey if a samurai needs a lighter who is going to say no? Who knew?

Kosuke-tagane [worm eaten] around the rim something a few smiths used including Nobuiye, Saotome or even Jingo amongst others. Not much help in narrowing it down. Reminds me a little of one of mine - maybe just the wide rim? Still no help as I can't put an attribution on mine!

Okan, I would say it comes from something original not too dissimilar to these perhaps?

Piers -