Corry Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 Does this maker make water quenched Gendaito 1945 ((IKKANSAI KUNIMORi) This has a wavy Hamon. Chris Bowen is NOT welcome to reply. Its 1945, no showa stamp: Rgds, Sterling Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 According to the seller, "Ask if Ikkansai Kunimori (Yasuhiro) made showato/oil-tempered swords. You will get lots of laughs." Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stephen Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 You're not going to get a lot of different response than Facebook what's already been told to you Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 11 hours ago, Stephen said: You're not going to get a lot of different response than Facebook what's already been told to you The only person who was arguing with me was Chris Bowen. That is not an answer. Assuming You've seen the post??? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mywei Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 Yes this is a gendaito Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 2 minutes ago, mywei said: Yes this is a gendaito Matt, just out of curiosity, what are your reasons? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mywei Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 I'm not an expert on gendaito but afaik the ikkansai Smiths made gendaito, and have been papered by the nbthk See 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bruce Pennington Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 I know nothing about this Smith, but here is what Slough said: 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stephen Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 Cory i take that back. It must of escalated after I left I'll go try to find it. Do NOT dismiss Chris B opinion. He's top authority on blades of that era. Id read the above link Mywei posted. Is that everything you can learn about your sword is in that . 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Brian Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 Just an opinion, but this doesn't look like Showato to me. It's carefully and well signed and finished off. Now that isn't conclusive...but it leads to an opinion. Hamon looks better than oil quenched. 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 3 hours ago, Stephen said: Cory i take that back. It must of escalated after I left I'll go try to find it. Do NOT dismiss Chris B opinion. He's top authority on blades of that era. Id read the above link Mywei posted. Is that everything you can learn about your sword is in that . Doesn't mean he is right about everything!. There are plentry of 3rd reich "experts that are wrong the time. I see it LOTS. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stephen Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 Your set on what you want to believe, far be it form me to try to change your mind. Im out 2 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 58 minutes ago, Stephen said: Your set on what you want to believe, far be it form me to try to change your mind. Im out Stephen, honestly, thanks for your thoughts on this. I am not saying you or even Chris are wrong. There just seems to be a lot of controversy about this. I mostly specialize in 3rd reich..about 1/3rd of my collection and am a subject matter expert on a few items and I get fooled once in a great while until I look REALLY closely. I have also seen this happen to other highly experienced collectors that have authored books on the subject. Another 1/3 of my collection is Imperial Japanese. I know a lot about NCO's etc, (but those are easy,fakes are getting better all the time tho..on a scary level) but am not anywhere near an expert on Gendaito.(thats why I am here I just am trying to figure it out?. Seems to have the correct features of gendaito, maybe I am wrong. I don't want to get burned, because this was not cheap. I also, don't want to screw over the seller if he is correct. I have provided him with a link to this discussion, in case he wants to defend his point of view. He has been in business for 10-15 years. I don't think he would still be around if he was unethical, but as stated, even experts miss things and make mistakes. Best Regards, Corry Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 All, Thanks for your input on this. Still looking for more info, so please chime in, if you have further to add. Best Regards, Corry Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 8 hours ago, Bruce Pennington said: I know nothing about this Smith, but here is what Slough said: Thanks Bruce, I have always known you to be knowledgeable and a straight shooter. I don't comment much, but stalk the page a bit. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 I do owe Chris Bowen an apology, even if It turns out to actually be a Gendaito. He spent the time to give me his thoughts and I was not a gentleman. I was a bit animated and over reacted on FB. I don't expect to be able to rejoin the page though. I wish him the best! Best Regards, Corry 4 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
David Flynn Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 Chris Bowen is not infallible. I saw this post on FB. His whole argument for Kunimori swords being Showato, comes from some very old articles and hearesay. I do however think that like a lot of us, we were given a lot of mis-information in the old days. Many myths and erroneous information has now been found out and altered. But here we are 2021 and there's those who still endorse these myths and erroneous mis-truths. Ikkansai Kunimori, are Gendaito. The have proper Jihada, they are water tempered and have a distict Nioguchi. Also, they get papered. 4 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stephen Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 The papers Steve M show in the link should pretty much end the discussion. I've been into Nihonto for close to 30 years and I still make mistakes. I don't know what you paid but you're not getting ripped off with the Kunimori. 2 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
matthewbrice Posted September 12 Report Share Posted September 12 Everyone knows Ikkansai Kunimori swords to be gendai. Everyone who offers one for sale—all the names in the business state they are gendai. Here are even just a very few examples: http://www.nihonto.us/IKANSAI KUNIMORI TACHI JP.htm http://swordsworld.blogspot.com/2009/02/gendai-swordsmiths-papered-by-nbthk-or.html?m=1 https://japanesesword.com/archived-pages/2017/7/28/gendaito-bymiyaguchi-kunimori —Matt 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corry Posted September 12 Author Report Share Posted September 12 OK, I should have enough info to make an informed decision. Thanks for all your thoughts and links! Much appreciated! Best Regards, Corry Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.