Lewis B

I certainly didn't read it as a reference to a specific person, more a generalisation around some recent and not so recent forum 'contributions' that are giving the NMB an unwelcoming and, can I say aggressive, vibe. The newbies are certainly getting it in the neck and whilst many of the comments and opinions are often valid, it's the delivery that can be tempered. As has been said many times, unless new members are encouraged, guided and supported in a positive way, the forum will eventually decline as the old guard move on, so to speak. Perhaps it's the pressures around Christmas so maybe it's a good moment to step back, take a breather and then return with a refreshed mind. I've really enjoyed @KungFooey's enthusiastic posts, comments and recent acquisitions and it would be sad to see her go especially under these circumstances. Hopefully after a little reflection any departure will be temporary. A no comment thread for people to show their blades would be very welcome. The 'Rai' Kuniyuki tachi is the quality of blade we need to see more of around here.

Nice Kamakura era daisho set. Ichimonji Nosada (Kanesada). The short wakizashi was originally a Naginata with early example of his Mei. I see these selling for a somewhat lower price if sold separately. https://www.tsurugin...om/items/f00668.html

Personally I think it is best to avoid Ebay, Catawiki, obscure auction houses and Gumtree/Craigslist, especially if you are new to collecting. I've seen FAR better blades recently, with papers, for a similar price on this forum. Ebay, Yahoo.jp/Jauce is a minefield and you'll only get burned... unless very lucky.

This a good starter reference for nihonto flaws. https://www.Japanese...rdindex.com/kizu.htm

Thats my birthday.... just sayin'

You'll be able to watch its discovery in one of the BBC's upcoming Digging for Britain episodes.

If it was my waki and I valued it.... then no. Several tried and tested products mentioned regularly on the forum.

Depends how much you value your waki

I'm a member. Joined this year so I could attend the NBTHK-EB meetings and for the Shinsa discount.

Can you post some clear images of the kissaki and boshi?

Yes, Camellia oil, branded as Tsubaki. There are a couple of species so get the one for blades. Never had any issues applying this sparingly on my swords and Japanese kitchen knives.

Overlooking the usual green paper concerns I see a blade thats in very poor condition and over polished. Shame the seller doesn't give the motokasane and sakikasane measurements. Hamon extends beyond the Ha, Hamachi virtually non existent. Bohi is narrow along the blade vs the nakago. Odd looking boshi and areas of shintetsu.

Even the horimono is exquisite. Far better than some full size carvings. A complete tour de force. I would love to know the story and why such a minute piece was created, mimicking its normal sized siblings in every detail and construction. I've certainly not seen another.

Reminds me of an apprentice piece. Super cute and looks well made.

From the bits I can read it appears Tanobe liked it and no arguments there.

Crossed my mind but then I noticed the blade cushion. All good. Fine sword in what appears to be nice polish. Would love to see some pics of the activity.

Everything about this area gives me pause for concern. The way the hamon drops off, the general sugata around the machi, especially towards the nakago. I get the feel of an abura quenched blade although not seeing the telltale secondary peaks. Higher rez images would be helpful. Load them onto a google drive folder where you don't have file size limits unlike on NMB.

Its still an auction without reserve so will sell for the highest bid assuming its not pulled before it closes.

Seems at first glance to be a bit of a bargain with early registration papers.

Which could have been yesterday. Tsuruta san is very astute and the papers say Awataguchi and not Hisakuni so they don't have a clear attribution to a specific maker, despite the sayagaki. For me this would be a blade to appreciate but not own.

Jedediah, since you saw the blade in person were you able to see this feature. Could this be a further fracture extending up from the Ha to the shinogi-ji (it's clearer in AOI's images)? It passed Juyo in 1981 but there is no mention or image of the massive kirikomi in the Zufu. Is it possible the damage was sustained after 1981? Would the stricter Shinsa today mean this type of damage would prevent it getting higher than TH papers?

What was the auction site? Has the whiff of shill bidding (by the seller) judging by the repeated MO. Thanks for flagging this seller. Would be nice if they can respond and clarify the matter.

But there will be hefty import tax and duties imposed when shipping to the EU, now that the UK is a 3rd country.

Well that was the price I was quoted by the dealer back in June.

Thats TokoJu is described as a kodachi. Hard to see the jihada or hataraki, but it appears to have utsuri. Perfect condition though as you would expect.