John C Posted October 9 Report Posted October 9 Disregard the seller and look at the blade. This could be a good one for a collection. https://www.ebay.com/itm/357721093608? John C. Quote
lonely panet Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 im going to go straight to the hamon ahahhahaha, wrong. way to thick construction is always Hira zukuri. not kanmaru Otoshi for the nihonto taren kai and the old chalk/powder filled mei is a tactic used to cover a fresh mei. and the metal is lifeless, like elon musks personality. never a chance in a snowballs hell that this "new: tanto was ever shoshin. Quote
Guest When Necessary Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 I must admit I've never seen a Yasukuni tanto which wasn't hirazukuri (and I've been looking at them for 20 years now). Quote
Guest When Necessary Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 Showa22 on the left, Tokuho papered Yasutoku on the right. I've only compared part of the date in the second photo but looking at the signature should be enough. Quote
Volker62 Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 earlier dated Yasukuni Tanto have mitsu mune Quote
ROKUJURO Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 The pictures are not very good. The blade may indeed be HIRA-ZUKURI, but the wide BOHI may give a wrong impression of a SHINOGI. Quote
Guest When Necessary Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 Regardless of the shape, the mei is fake. I just sent Showa22 an eBay PM telling him the same - so I'm waiting for the inevitable "Eff off and mind your own business" reply. Quote
Michael 67 Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 Volker, I know that tanto from somewhere 😉. Here's my Yasunori from my collection for comparison. 2 Quote
John C Posted October 10 Author Report Posted October 10 The Yamashiro style jiri seems a bit different as well. The OP is straighter across rather than that slight upturn typical of Yasunori. John C. Quote
Hokke Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 (edited) Definitely not hira zukuri….looks more like kanmuriotoshi-zukuri? Edited October 10 by Hokke 1 Quote
Volker62 Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 let's get back to the point Michael what kind of Mune shape does your beautiful YasunoriTanto have? A mitsumune too? Quote
Volker62 Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 interesting one might be think, that with the intensity of the war, individual production steps were simplyfied??, because as can beseen in the graphic in tom Kishid's book, the production number of manufactered blades increased. to what extent this alsso affects the rarer Tanto blades cannot be confirmed certainly. Quote
Volker62 Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 yes,thank you Eric Molinier, who sent this beautiful Tanto Yasunori Tanto to Germany to Michael67 Quote
ROKUJURO Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 6 hours ago, Hokke said: Definitely not hira zukuri….looks more like kanmuriotoshi-zukuri? You are (almost) correct Calabrese, in the description (which I should have read before writing....) the SUGATA is mentioned: UNOKUBI-ZUKURI (鵜首造): 1 Quote
Guest When Necessary Posted October 10 Report Posted October 10 This is the response I received from Showa22 after pointing out his tanto was gimei. His reply speaks volumes. Quote
Hokke Posted October 11 Report Posted October 11 4 hours ago, ROKUJURO said: which I should have read before writing... You and I both......ah well, one day I'll get something right, then I'll know it's time to hang it up and retire on an upnote 1 Quote
Rawa Posted October 11 Report Posted October 11 He really have some more https://ebay.us/m/bzIyx4 Quote
Guest When Necessary Posted October 11 Report Posted October 11 We 48 minutes ago, Rawa said: He really have some more https://ebay.us/m/bzIyx4 Well, now that I've shown him a real one, he's probably gotten his chisel guy to copy that onto all his mumei gunto. Quote
Rawa Posted October 11 Report Posted October 11 Just now, When Necessary said: We Well, now that I've shown him a real one, he's probably gotten his chisel guy to copy that onto all his mumei gunto. This one have tokuho. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.