Foletta Posted July 22, 2020 Report Posted July 22, 2020 Could I have some feedback on this mei please . I did find a mei on this site looked close, seems to be alot of copies around . 62.2 cm long small Katana in late war Kaigunto mounts Thank you Geoff Quote
Jacques Posted July 22, 2020 Report Posted July 22, 2020 very likely gimei This one is juyo http://www.sword-auction.jp/sites/default/files/151037-2.jpg Quote
Ken-Hawaii Posted July 27, 2020 Report Posted July 27, 2020 Geoff, please don't get hung up on mei! Look at the blade first. Is the sugata correct? How about the jigane? Does the hamon match? Unless you've identified these kantei points, looking at the mei is useless. Take a look at https://to-ken.uk/resources/kantei.html for more details. And please remember that the vast majority of blades are gimei. Quote
Jacques Posted July 27, 2020 Report Posted July 27, 2020 Geoff, please don't get hung up on mei! Look at the blade first. Is the sugata correct? How about the jigane? Does the hamon match? Unless you've identified these kantei points, looking at the mei is useless. Take a look at https://to-ken.uk/resources/kantei.html for more details. And please remember that the vast majority of blades are gimei. Useless, dear Ken, unless you know perfectly the workmanship ot the smith in question (which needs years of serious studies). Quote
Tom Darling Posted July 27, 2020 Report Posted July 27, 2020 For example, knowing the quality of the blade, takes a long period of time ( hundreds of blades) to reasonably understand, what you have in hand, with two good eyes and proper lighting. When this is accomplished you'll be near knowing half as much of what you don't know. Some collectors, can take a blade out of the scabbard five to ten inches (only) to determine if it's worth further study. Good luck. Happy Trail's. Peace. Tom D. Quote
16k Posted July 27, 2020 Report Posted July 27, 2020 All I can say is that if gimei (probable), the faker did a rather good job at reproducing the strokes. Quote
Surfson Posted July 29, 2020 Report Posted July 29, 2020 Geoff, there are nine generations. Based on this date, I think that it could only be 7, 8 or 9. If it's gimei, it is probably purporting to be 7, since he is the most famous, along with the first generation. I haven't studied the mei, but I have a 7th generation and am attaching a photo of the mei. Quote
Surfson Posted July 29, 2020 Report Posted July 29, 2020 I made a side by side comparison, but the site wouldn't let me upload it for some reason. It isn't a bad likeness. I will try again on the next box. Quote
Surfson Posted July 29, 2020 Report Posted July 29, 2020 The last two kanji on yours, which I think say "sei-tan" or respectfully made, are pretty different. I am leaning toward it not being 7th generation or being gimei of 7. You will need examples of 8th and 9th generations. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.