NewB Posted July 25, 2024 Report Posted July 25, 2024 Hello members id appreciate if you’d be so nice and willing to give me translation of the papers of the 2 blades below. Thank you in advance yv Quote
NewB Posted July 26, 2024 Author Report Posted July 26, 2024 Last Noshu Kanemoto thank you @Ray Singer yv Quote
Nobody Posted July 26, 2024 Report Posted July 26, 2024 1. Wakizashi Mumei: Thought to be 宗弘 (Munehiro) in Fukuoka (福岡) Late Showa era 2. Katana Mumei: Thoght to be Kanemoto (兼元) in Noshu (濃州) Circa Tensho (天正, 1573-1592) 4 1 Quote
NewB Posted July 26, 2024 Author Report Posted July 26, 2024 None of the attributions fit the blades if that’s Showa rust on the nakago then I’m definitely in the wrong sport… yv Quote
Shugyosha Posted July 26, 2024 Report Posted July 26, 2024 Maybe the earlier Showa starting 1312? But then again, it doesn't look that early to me as there's a substantial hamachi... Quote
Nobody Posted July 26, 2024 Report Posted July 26, 2024 32 minutes ago, Shugyosha said: Maybe the earlier Showa starting 1312? But then again, it doesn't look that early to me as there's a substantial hamachi... That is another Showa. The paper says late Showa: 昭和 (1926 - 1989). 1 Quote
NewB Posted July 26, 2024 Author Report Posted July 26, 2024 Im not criticizing the shinsa team but there’s absolutely no way this is a late showa blade especially after looking at other examples of the smith. Not even close… and that is Kanemoto? I’m just sooo confused and definitely disappointed I accept that shinsa is only an opinion but that opinion shouldn’t be centuries apart.. yv Quote
NewB Posted July 26, 2024 Author Report Posted July 26, 2024 15 hours ago, Shugyosha said: Maybe the earlier Showa starting 1312? But then again, it doesn't look that early to me as there's a substantial hamachi... .. and substantial machi okuri… yv Quote
Tohagi Posted July 26, 2024 Report Posted July 26, 2024 I understand your point of view, this nakago des not look showa at all. Not even shinto IMO.... Artificialy elder? ... Black rust FeO3 takes usualy 300 years or more... Best, Éric VD 1 Quote
NewB Posted July 27, 2024 Author Report Posted July 27, 2024 2 hours ago, Tohagi said: I understand your point of view, this nakago des not look showa at all. Not even shinto IMO.... Artificialy elder? ... Black rust FeO3 takes usualy 300 years or more... Best, Éric VD I respect you chiming in - Indeed you’re right no smell no evidence of tempering (artificial aging) black rust as nambokucho and the latter and then the 2nd one - that’s Kanemoto? Or Kanemitsu :D or earlier … no clue.. thank you for the input nonetheless ! apparently nbthk remains the last resort for dreamers as myself lol dont mind the irony yv Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.