john sloughs book of oshigata's and its use on ebay

[lonely panet]

Hi fellow humans,

Iv had this question on my mind for months now, the book by J.S Slough and how many times its been used as a tool for dealers on Ebay to there perosnal gain, many times getting the smith they claim who made there sword mixed up with a higher rated one to help increase the final sale price of there item.

 

If this is the case should the author be entitled to some for of royalty?

 

Im trying open a can of worms out of frustration, as less experanced collectors my be unfairly over paying on the word of a dealer or seller whom some have no problems with being dishonest.

 

regards Hamish (the can opener of worms)

[J Reid]

That's why it's recommended to buy books, go to shows, learn, and then buy blades (from reputable dealers). Ebay is never a recommended place to shop as a novice. As for royalities... Noo. The books are being used for reference only.

[Grey Doffin]

Hamish,

Those who post the pictures on ebay have bought the book. The author has been compensated; all is well.

Grey

[Pete Klein]

JFYI: http://www.nihontomessageboard.com/nmb/ ... =9&t=11450

[lonely panet]

I think the point i was trying to make was missed , but thanks for the link that was posted.

In respectfull thought of the Slough family, I was unaware of his passing and end this post.

regards Hamish