Hi all,
I just wanted to make a couple of comments about some of the topics raised here. Regarding unsigned Showa era swords that were pinked at the SF shinsa. We have always rejected such blades at shinsa in Japan, and do so at shinsa outside of Japan. The reason is not just one of quality, but is in regards to Japanese laws. All Showa era swords must be signed by law. Modern unsigned swords have been altered for reasons that have nothing to do with usage, which is somethat that could be claimed for swords dating to before the ban on wearing swords during the early Meiji period (there may be some exceptions to this, but only one i can think of). Such alterations are illegal and are attempts to hide something, such as the modern period of manufacture. In many cases, but not all, the nakago has been worked on to make the blade appear older. I do not know for certain, but I expect the NBTHK would do the same thing.
Secondly, this was a very tough shinsa. The standards for acceptance were extremely high. I did have some heated discussions on a number of swords that I thought should have been papered. In a few cases, I successfully got opinions to change, but most of the time, the team discussion resulted in a rejection. If you got a paper at the SF shinsa, you can rest assured that it will be a paper with some value. I have not seen the final numbers, but I would not be surprised if we passed less than 50% of the swords submitted. This was not the case with fittings. The quality level here seems to have been much higher, and while the standards for pass were just as rigorous as with swords, I believe the pass rate was close to 80%. There were fewer fittings submissions, but the fittings people seem to be pretty good with their stuff. I also expect that since fittings are cheaper, it is harder to pay for a $250 paper when your tsuba is only worth $500.
Finally, I had a great time seeing lots of old friends and making a few new ones. I was sorry I missed most of the show, but from what I could tell, I wasn't the only one having a good time.
Gordon