Jump to content

Good Sword

Meijin
 Share

Recommended Posts

AndreasU Collaborator

AndreasU

Posted
Posted

Sorry guys,

 

even that I am a beginner with swords I lerned the following:

 

It is impossible to judge a sword only by pictures.

I doubt that you can see by these few pics that it is oil tempered.

The rust on the tang looks normal to me. It is a photo and colours will change drastically using a flash, especially if there is dust (rust) on a surface

The Tsuka same, hey c'mon what do you expect? That there is the original Tsuka left from Edo era?? It is crystal clear that the whole kishirae is new.

Anyway its unimportant because the "sword" is not the koshirai.

 

The sword was shortened minimum twice. This shows that the pre owners were very satisfied with the swords abilitys.

 

 

One of the polishers polished a bit too much the ppart of the habaki. Thats the only thing I would say this looks strange but pleas correct me.

 

Andreas

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Stever Collaborator

Stever

Posted
Posted

Just my thoughts on this blade, entirely possible that I have no idea what I'm talking about...

 

Hamon looks oil hardened to me, I have yet to see a traditionally made blade with a habuchi that looks like that. Also, I've seen a couple of sambonsugi showa blades that look very similar to this one. Also seems kind of inactive even though it is pretty. Not sure about the hada, either.

 

Nakago definitely looks strange, appears to have been shortened once, but possibly as a deception(?); the shape seems to have been modified somehow. Rust/patina is weird, too. It's very fine and uniform, but there is no yasurimei visible and it seems quite worn, so I'd expect the rust to be a bit rougher. Looks like a newly-applied patina to me.

 

As I said, just my thoughts. Did this more as an exercise, really. Still, looks like a fairly nice blade. Price seems to have ended where most showato are ending up nowadays on eBay.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Henry Wilson Veteran

Henry Wilson

Posted
Posted

The nakago on the top two intial swords look strange to me.

 

F22 Raptor wrote

It is impossible to judge a sword only by pictures.

 

That is true but I think that the gentlemen above are not trying to spoil your post, just giving their opinions based on what they see.

 

 

The sword was shortened minimum twice. This shows that the pre owners were very satisfied with the swords abilitys.

 

Have you determined this from the pictures?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Bushido01 Enthusiast

Bushido01

Posted
Posted
Even if that other one isn't showa, here's one that is that's much nicer (to me)...

 

http://cgi.ebay.ca/GENDAITO-Japanese-SAMURAI-SWORD-NIHONTO-WW2-ARMY-GUNTO_W0QQitemZ270112590920QQihZ017QQcategoryZ43338QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

 

Although some of the lines in the mei seem a bit off. Gimei, perhaps?

 

This balde seems to have a few chips on the edge and potential small hagiri, be careful.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Deron Douglas Enthusiast

Deron Douglas

Posted
Posted
well check his other out:

http://cgi.ebay.com/Japanese-sword-Nori ... dZViewItem

 

let me know your thoughts

 

And that signature looks aweful... or was that mentioned?

 

I bought my first sword of ebay, but I was REALLY lucky. I got it from a trust worthy fellow in the US who is/was a member of this board. Although I didn't know it at the time. He helped me through the process, it was a lot of money for me, but I "had to have it". To this day it is my best and favourite sword. It's mounted now and looks incredible. But I got lucky!

 

I shutter now at how easily I put down my hard earned money. I don't think I would ever buy a sword from eBay again. I don't have the nerves for it. After talking with people and learning from this board. I've become attuned to the rip-offs and scams.

 

I'll leave all the good deals on eBay for Milt :-)

 

Cheers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jean

Jean

Posted
Posted

I love this discussion. It is only an opinion, Nihonto is made of exception :

 

- It is impossible to judge a blade from pictures

 

I am wondering why are all these Japanese Nihonto books full of pictures published!, :)

I am sorry to say that I do not agree having a lot of admiration for Darcy and its pictures kantei.

 

- Nakago : I dislike the bohi ans its shape, it should follow the curve of the sword, the signature has red dust and does not match any oshigata on my Nihonto Zuikan

I dislike the way the bohi ends near the mekugi ana

 

- Sorry for the contradiction, but the signature (I doubt it's genuine) and the nearest mekugi ana show that the sword has been shortened only once

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Stever Collaborator

Stever

Posted
Posted

This balde seems to have a few chips on the edge and potential small hagiri, be careful.

 

Thanks, didn't notice the hagire. Which pic did you see that in? I'm not bidding just looking but still, as you say, be careful out there.

 

On that note, I noticed this auction as well:

http://cgi.ebay.ca/Truthfull-description-of-SAMURIA-SWORD_W0QQitemZ300104164673QQihZ020QQcategoryZ47347QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

Nice to see some honesty for a change.

 

cheers,

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Red Anjin Apprentice

Red Anjin

Posted
Posted

Hi,

I'm very new to the board, and swords in general and I had a few questions/observations.

 

Looking at the second sword, does the hamon look too regular or is that sort of uniformity common? In parts it looks almost like the exact same pattern repeated over and over down the length of the blade.

 

I think he said it was shortened twice because the older hole (farther down the tang) is in such a location that the tsuka would have partially covered the groove (sorry, can't remember the proper term right now) that runs down the blade. If this is normally covered than that hole could be the original, if not, then it would have had to be shorteded to it. The second hole would be the second shortening as the groove is now 2/3 the way down the tsuka.

 

Thanks,

Red Anjin

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Stever Collaborator

Stever

Posted
Posted

The hamon is sambonsugi, which is supposed to be a repeating pattern as far as I know. Some are more consistent than others; there is much variation. Sometimes the smith seems to be going for perfect repetition, sometimes they take a more artistic approach. All depends on what he wanted to do, methinks.

 

I think he said it was shortened twice because the older hole (farther down the tang) is in such a location that the tsuka would have partially covered the groove (sorry, can't remember the proper term right now) that runs down the blade. If this is normally covered than that hole could be the original, if not, then it would have had to be shorteded to it. The second hole would be the second shortening as the groove is now 2/3 the way down the tsuka.

 

Were this true, that would put the signature onto the blade itself, or under the habaki in the original configuration, so either the signature is fake (likely), or this is a story to try to explain the strange nakago shape (also likely). That's my opinion, anyway.

 

I don't say this much, and I know it doesn't come out in my posts, but if anyone thinks differently I'd love to hear it and why. I'm just learning, too, and it's entirely possible I'm wrong (even probable), so any other opinions are always welcome.

 

cheers

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Brian

Brian

Posted
Posted

Too late once it arrives to discover if it is or isn't a hagire.

I would certainly ask a seller if it looked like a crack or not,　and determine what kind of post sales service you can expect if it turns out to be one. Always pays to be cautious.

 

Brian

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest Nanshoku-Samurai

Guest Nanshoku-Samurai

Posted
Posted

Hello Andreas,

 

I am sorry but have to wholeheartetly disagree with you. After having spend many years on eBay I absolutely believe that you can judge a blade from pictures, even if the blade is in bad condition and there are only poor pictures available. The golden rule is: Be prepared that what you get is even worse than what it had looked like. You can easily tell an oil quenched blade by the pictures.

 

Regards,

 

Max

Link to comment
Share on other sites
roninjje Enthusiast

roninjje

Posted
Posted

I agree, you can tell oil tempering, especially that swords, a mile away.

When you handle enough swords, look at enough good sword porn ;) you then get pretty intuitive. What kills me is poor lighting at gun shows, even holding a sword in hand if the lighting is poor it can be difficult.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
This thread is quite old. Please consider starting a new thread rather than reviving this one, unless your post is really relevant and adds to the topic..

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...