Jump to content

Jean

Moderators
  • Posts

    8,624
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    52

Posts posted by Jean

  1. I am devastated, I have known him for decades since he posted a Miike sword for kantei that I identified. Among my best blades in my Gokaden collection, I got the Naoe Shizu and the Tametsugu from him. We exchanged alot along the years discussing the Aoi Art weekly kantei. I met him and Curran in Japan during my last DTI. I’ll miss him.

    I remember when he told me he had discussed at length my Hôsho/Tegai blade with Bobby and Guido. They were the 3 Musketeers, remains only Bobby.

    My mind is in turmoil…

    • Like 2
  2. Really a wrong move. Proper training is needed and not everyone is able to become a good polisher, there is a big selection. I am really surprised. I remember 20 years ago, a French NMB member visited Aoi Art shop and told me that he found a bucket full of water and at the bottom polishing stones.

    Tsuruta san indulges himself in polishing.

  3. Just to precise, my former NBTHK Kanekiyo blade, had 2 sayagaki one by Honma Junji and the other one by Tanobe sensei, both to Hosho. It is very very rare that NBTHK overwrites Honma Junji opinion (without mentionning Tanobe). It happens more often with Kanzan Sato’s.

    • Like 1
  4. Yes, and the main problem comes from the fact that NBTHK does not precize in the kanteisho the smith generation.

    First generation Kanekiyo forged in Masame.

     

    http://www.sho-shin.com/yam8.htm

    KANEKIYO(1) -1326- KA-REKI (f: KANENAGA 1): Made HIRA-TSUKURI, UCHI-ZORI         MITSU-MUNE TANTO. Running MASAME veiled in JI-NIE and          NIE-UTSURI. HADA shows CHIKEI.          Shallow NOTARE KO-GUNOME HA in KO-NIE and NIOI. SUNAGASHI         and KINSUJI.         BOSHI runs TOGARI on the grain, with HAKIKAKE-KAERI.          KURIJIRI NAKAGO with HIGAKI YASURI. 

  5. How NBTHK can kantei?

     

    is kantei so easy, when we refer to Tsuruta comments?

     

    https://www.aoijapan.com/119465-2/

     

    Tsuruta comment: « Ouei swords usually is Muji style and has Bizen style Ko-Itame-hada like this sword. »

     

    My former Oei tachi signed Yasumitsu:


    is it really muji?

     

    https://www.aoijapan.com/katanamumei-tegai-kanekiyo/
     

    Tsuruta comment Tegai’s Jigane does not have Masame Hada. It has Itame Hada and Mokume Hada. 


    my former papered tegai Kanekiyo:

     

     

    my former NBTHK papered Kanekiyo is pure masame with sayagaki by Honma Junji and Michihiro Tanobe to Hosho. NBTHK overpassed Honma Junji and Michihiro Tanobe’s opinion..for Kanekiyo who according Tsuruta san did not forge in masame.


     

    • Like 2
    • Haha 2
×
×
  • Create New...