sc72 Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago I've seen a Tanto in shirasaya that interests me, maybe gimei...but I'm unsure whether it's a genuine Tamahagane. I only have these photos of the blade. I'd like an opinion. There are traces of rust (in spots), and the nagako looks good. The blade leaves me skeptical. But I could be wrong. Also, the era (it could be Meiji, assuming it's Tamahagane). I'm not linking the address out of respect for the seller. Quote
ROKUJURO Posted 7 hours ago Report Posted 7 hours ago Stefano, a nice OSORAKU blade! They were often made in SHIN-SHINTO era as revival pieces. Could we see the NAKAGO please (not Nagako !)? How do you want to determine if it is made from TAMAHAGANE unless you can see a clear HADA (which is not a guarantee but a greater likelihood)? There are spectroscopic methods to get a precise steel analysis. Quote
sc72 Posted 6 hours ago Author Report Posted 6 hours ago What leaves me perplexed is that ...from the photos... the metal looks (like that of industrial gunto swords) without the metal having any activity. Quote
Lewis B Posted 5 hours ago Report Posted 5 hours ago I wonder if there has been some acid etchant used or other shenanigans to augment the features. Quote
Lewis B Posted 3 hours ago Report Posted 3 hours ago Seller appears to be the same guy behind Komonjo or at least affiliated with him. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.