Alex A Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 Briefly, taking a closer look at the nakago and other features that are clear, reminds me of an Osaka Shinto. The nakago, jigane, hamon. Not saying it is, but that's where i would start to look as that what it reminds me of. 2 Quote
Jacques Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 Due to the measurements, i would exclude Kanbun shinto Quote
Alex A Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 Why Jacques? Can you rule out the possibility that the sword was ordered those dimensions during Kanbun?. Sori of 0.6mm makes me think Kanbun. Im not saying it is Kanbun, just curious. Reminds of an Osaka sword i had dating to around mid 1700s. Quote
Alex A Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 Ps, out of curiosity. Does anyone else kind of think that the mid 1700s always comes across as a bit of an oddball era for Japanese swords?. As in it feels like compared to other times, less is said about that era. Maybe its just me , dunno. 1 Quote
Jacques Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 Kanbun shinto is not only sori.... which is a little bit too small https://sanmei.com/contents/en-us/p2456.html https://www.samuraimuseum.jp/shop/product/antique-Japanese-sword-wakizashi-signed-by-mino-no-kami-jyumyo-nbthk-hozon-certificate/?srsltid=AfmBOoqVUWsHsgkZy6PEPij9PiZLhZ4qD1V6kzd08nsNon0uVIOT1156 Quote
Alex A Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 Of course, its just that when folks talk of Kanbun Sugata it usually means little sori. Though seen loads of that era with the more usual sori, just bought one in fact. This is what im talking about. It used to be mine many years ago. Though back then it didnt have the marks on the blade, had NTHK papers and was a lot cheaper. It was almost straight with sori of 0.6mm, from memory. The Lanes Armoury | A Beautiful Shinto Katana By Kaga Kiyomitsu With NTHK Kanteisho Papers Kanbun blades of that sori can get you good deals on the bigger name smiths, if your ok with that shape, that is. Quote
Jacques Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 Things are always relative, when we speak of little sori it's in relation to the previous or the following era. That said, the major characteristic of Kanbun shinto is on tapering = a notable difference (1cm or more) between moto haba and saki haba (1 cm or more). I don't trust NTHK (once i sent a katana with NTHK papers to NBTHK shinsa and that katana turned to be gimei....). 1 Quote
Alex A Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 KANTEI 1 – SUGATA #6 | Markus Sesko Curiously, Osaka smiths gets a mention for adopting Kanbun Sugata. 1 Quote
Jacques Posted July 15 Report Posted July 15 Not only Osaka smiths , and others are missing such Tadayoshi school Quote Edo-shintô smiths like Kazusa no Suke Kaneshige (上総介兼重), Yamato no Kami Yasusada (大和守安定), schools like the Nagasone (長曾禰) school (Kotetsu [虎徹], Okimasa [興正]); the Hôjôji (法城寺) school (Masahiro [正弘], Yoshitsugu [吉次]); the 2nd generation Sendai Kunikane (国包), Miyoshi Nagamichi (三善長道). Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.