Hi Grey, Yes it has been beat up, there are file marks all along the blade. I have heard people remark on the curve off the blade as well. Do you think it could of been caused by someone sharpening it on a steel, like you do before you carve your roast dinner. The person who owned it was very ignorent of its history, exept that it was brought back by her decendent Captain Francis Stuart who was an 1800's sea captain.