Jump to content

Jim P

Members
  • Posts

    488
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by Jim P

  1. Hi Kevin, I don’t post much these days but I thought this was funny!! they sell samurai jeans

    So a bit of advice if a sword shop sell swords for 16k and sells samurai jeans too it should  give you a big ?

    https://www.samuraim...ory/ryukyu-ai-denim/

    It has been said repeatedly on this board be suspicious of old papers coming out of Japan

    Also, he gives a good rendition of the Ujisada story but he does not state its by him

    Only this blade is attributed to Ujisada<_< 

  2. Hi Ray I thought Sue-Bizen  too, like Morimitsu look at the boshi and hada found  on a similar one on aoi https://www.aoijapan.net/katana-bishu-osafune-morimitsu-sakusue-bizen/   but a quick look at Sue-Bizen and you get mostly Torii Sori but you see Koshi Sori { Bizen Sori } in this sword so its off the norm for a later time it’s probably  from the early Sue-Bizen ? but I can’t shake the feeling its got a lot of shinto in it ?

  3.  Hi Tom,If sharpness or a dull edge was of great importance then that's something that would be on papers which it’s not nor do most of the nihonto sites in Japan speak of sharp or a dull blade take Aoi Art for example because it depends what the sword is cutting. If they ground them like razors they would not do well on Japanese armour that's why we speak about the meat of a blade kitchen knives are flat ground swords are usually convex for good reasons a lot less chips and cracks. A polisher will always try to keep the meat or bevel of a blade I would take a dull Gorō Nyūdō Masamune over a sharp Komonjo special every time.  :laughing:

    post-893-0-84208500-1579683848_thumb.jpg

    • Like 3
  4. Hi Mark, You need to take some better photos the ones you posted will not tell us much. I would take the story with a pinch of salt same for the family crest also the papers ? are not from one of the main line appraisal orgs { NBTHK ,NTHK } they may be fine but you may find that if you put them in to NBTHK or NTHK you may not get the same result as papered daisho are very rare. So looking forward to photos of the bare blades this will help members see traits like sugata. hada, and hamon

     and you will get much better reply's :)  PS  photo 3 in your last post of the Wakizashi it looks like hamon runs off at the Kissaki but it may be the photo or my bad eyesight :dunno:  

  5. HI guys, Need some help with a hard one

    Thanks to Bazza and Steve M for their thoughts {Second character on the rhs is SHUU, the first being the province?. there is horimono on the blade so one of the lhs characters I think reads HORI DO SAKU ("also made the carving").}

    but not much on the rest at this point :-?  thoughts ?

     

    post-893-0-71599200-1550568317_thumb.jpg

    post-893-0-75864000-1550568325_thumb.jpg

  6. Hi Chris,IMHO, Don't know why you are using this blade to sharpen your skills, paulb has it right "looks Showa" sometimes you have to look at the seller this guy sells a lot of stuff that does not sell in Japan a quick look at the site tells you a lot :doubt:  If they thought edo they would tell you,what did the add say ?

  7. Hi Sil,

    Have a look at the strokes inside the kuni they don't match  also look at the strokes on the one above the 3 lines not centered it may be that the small differences  are changes over time? but IMHO don't think so. Only shinsa can help with blades like this :thumbsup:  unless you can find some more Oshigata :) from Index of Japanese Swordsmiths

    Kunitsugu (国次), 4th gen., Bunmei (文明, 1469-1487), Etchū– „Uda Kunitsugu“ (宇多国次), „Uda Kunitsugu saku“ (宇多国次作), Uda school, he lived in Etchū´s Kaganomiya (鏡宮), priest name „Jōkō“ (浄幸), gunome-midare or suguha,chūjō-saku

    post-893-0-44163600-1510980048_thumb.jpg

    post-893-0-09713200-1510984946_thumb.png

  8. Hi Sil,IMHO, I think I would take the view that it could be gimei ? or by a different smith  have a look at the Oshigata for the 4th from koto meikan and fujishiros K310 does not look like a good match so had a look at 3rd or 5th also no good have a look at some of the kanji eg, kuni is done with small differences that don't match the Oshigata for all of them and you can see differences in the other kanji hope that helps    :)

    post-893-0-80496400-1510904756_thumb.png

    post-893-0-58276100-1510904810_thumb.png

    post-893-0-05059900-1510905972_thumb.jpg

  9. Hi Sil, Is that your first name ? Had a quick look one of the other guys may have better references this is what I got :)
    Hawley list KUN1473 as 2nd generation.
    Fujishiros K310 does not look like a good match
    looks like they got the info from Nihonto Club  as they list it as
    Kunitsugu (4th gen) but does not match
    So, the rare nakamura samurai Sword needs more research ;-)

     

  10. Hi Guys, I have been asked to try and get some info on Swords that were acquired from Japan during the late 1880's to early 1900's. These weapons were apparently acquired from the Japanese Tokyo Arsenal and have posted parts of his email for your thoughts

     

    From the Historical museum, I was approached by a member of the public seeking some family history items. He has an avid interest in the arms and weaponry of the Australian military and asked if we might have any information, or examples of a batch and Swords acquired from Japan during the late 1880's to early 1900's. These weapons were apparently acquired from the Japanese Tokyo Arsenal during a period of severe budgetary restraint imposed by the effects of the great depression

    I have found Parliamentary records  which prove that a sample batch of Japanese swords was ordered by the Victorian Government in 1892 and that some 65 of these were imported into Victoria early in 1893.
    The Parliamentary record from Hansard dated Thursday 14 November 1901 confirms that the Victorian Government imported, as a sample, some swords from Japan and that 15 of these were allocated to the infantry and 50 to Cadet Corps officers.

     

    What type of swords do you think would have been imported ? Thanks
     

  11. Hi Luis, I also thought waklizashi came later, I also remember reading  Otanto or sunobi tanto were the companions to tachi or a Kodach as a indoor sword in the Nambokucho the problem is there is some who call them waklizashi both are right but for me and a lot of others Jeans explanation is how I would have explained it If I remember correctly the word Waklizashi came in to use after Nambokucho?

    Luis,you will find facts can be hard to pin down in the nihonto world. It is very easy to form a negative on the net and we all misinterpret from time to time when we don't know how that person expresses their thoughts. I can tell you Jeans only motive was to try and help so I think you have misinterpreted how the info was presented. I think you will have to send it to someone who can see it in hand as it stands  you still may have a sword worth polishing :)  

×
×
  • Create New...