Jump to content

Surfson

Gold Tier
  • Posts

    2,959
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    18

Posts posted by Surfson

  1. Especially some close up photos above the nakago ana on the side with the date.  I am curious as to whether the patch that appears to have been polished in some way may have remnants of an era in it.  

     

    I think it's an interesting older piece, probably early to mid muromachi.  

     

    I haven't studied the mei but my first inclination is that it is representing Tosa Yoshimitsu.  

     

    I think that this may be a better sword than you initially thought, and certainly worthy of more study. 

    • Like 1
  2. I think that more photos are in order and it might be an interesting piece.  I don't think that the mei was added recently.  In such a case, there is usually red rust in the carving of the mei, and this tanto doesn't have that.  Having half a date is odd, but it would be nice to see the whole tang and the whole sword.  

    • Like 1
  3. I just went back and looked at the Tanobe sayagaki for my Norishige (also a discovery - it was a unloved sword at a show).  In it, he uses Yuhin nari, which is very exciting to me considering what Markus told you.  Thank you for the useful information!

    • Like 1
  4. I can see the nie in the boshi now that it has been pointed out.  Sometimes the hamon is dark rather than light/white depending on the photography or sometimes the last polish (especially when amateurs polish a sword you can get this inversion of dark and light).  

  5. That's an interesting sword Mark.  As to the boshi, it may indicate that the tip was once broken and the new boshi after reshaping of the kissaki comes close to running off of the blade.  

  6. Will, I think that your instincts are pretty good, and we have seen so many newbies come up with much worse than this.  

     

    I do imagine it is 500 years old+.  It appears to have a ko-kissaki.  

     

    The tsuba is in poor shape but has an Umetada vibe to it based on the hitsuana.  

     

    It has a nice kurikata, indicating that it was probably in handachi mounts.  

     

    Finally, it looks to me like it was covered in cosmoline, and has never been cleaned.  One of the lines that looks like a ware in the shingoi ji is probably old cosmoline.  Having all of this old cosmoline suggests that it may not have ever been in the hands of a collector.  

     

    I'm not saying you should buy it because according to the seller it has a few ware.  However, I think that your interest in it was not unfounded.

×
×
  • Create New...