Jump to content

RichardP

Gold Tier
  • Posts

    202
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by RichardP

  1. Hello Adam!

    You might consider addressing the various points of entry into this field—you’ve got militaria enthusiasts whose natural interest in gunto seduced them into nihonto proper.  Then there are the martial artists, who may have been swinging iaito before they ever heard of hada, but have gone on to pursue the roots of their art in nihonto.  There are the artistic connoisseurs, who bring a strong aesthetic perspective that really gets at the heart of nihonto.  
    These categories will overlap of course, but by presenting and discussing them, a prospective buyer can do some necessary introspection and really start to drill down on WHY they are considering buying a nihonto.  (For example, someone whose interest in gunto is limited to its connection with WWII may be perfectly happy with a non-traditionally made blade, if that blade comes with wartime provenance.) 
    Each category will also present different issues regarding our obligations to be good stewards for these objects.  Does the buyer insist on accompanying koshirae?  Why?  That’s a major fork in the road right there.  If buyer wants koshirae so that the nihonto can be used for martial arts practice, does buyer understand the potential for damaging the nihonto in the process?  Does buyer realize that the cost of having modern koshirae made is not going to be recouped if the buyer ever wants to re-sell, and nihonto with matching, historic koshirae is both big bucks and now a big obligation to care for saya lacquerware?  If for the above reasons the buyer sours on the notion of koshirae, does the new notion of nihonto in shirasaya hold as much appeal as the old image of the samurai sword?  If not, maybe time to rethink things...

     

  2. On 1/15/2021 at 4:57 PM, Surfson said:

    He probably took a stone and ran it along the ha, making it dull.  I have seen dealers do this when there are small nail catcher chips.  It is easy for a potential buyer to overlook the fact that the ha has been reduced less than one mm.  

    Ughh—never thought of that, but of course there would be a financial incentive for unscrupulous dealers to do this.  (Always nice to learn even one more way the world can be awful...)

    • Like 1
  3. On 11/13/2020 at 6:36 PM, Bugyotsuji said:

    Thanks for the thought, but I think the older style were actually more difficult to use. The internal screw 'drift' is such a clever evolution. Only the two on the left in my photo above have this feature. (I have tried unsuccessfully to open the tops of the middle two.)

    These are so beautiful.

    Piers, could you—or someone—please clue me in as to what makes an internal screw a useful feature on a mekugi nuki?  

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...