Geraint

Dear Adam. For useful information on flaws see here. http://www.ksky.ne.jp/~sumie99/flaws.html Mukade = centipede, hence many shinae close together. Given what I said above you are correct that cleaning a nakago is a bad idea. Shinsakuto would start out with a pristine nakago and over time the patina rust will grow over the metal. Given ubu nakago it is useful to note the colour of the patina, nakago sabi, but of course if the original nakago disappears due to o suriage then you are starting again. All of this is influenced by the way the sword has been cared for and indeed handled. I recall that one Masamune had what would be described as Shinto nakago sabi because it was handled so often whereas a sword that has been largely neglected may have quite serious rust damage in a very short time. It is of course very hard to judge colour from monotone on line photographs, sellers don't usually bother with this particular feature very much. All the best.

Dear Adam. In both these cases I do not see cleaned nakago. Lighting has a lot to do with revealing the true colour, the first Takada blade has a nakago in good condition but the rest of what you are seeing is a lighting issue I think. Worth bearing in mind that we are looking at a blade which is stated to be Edo period and that could be quite recent. The second is heavily suriage so what is now the nakago is, in most part what would have been polished blade surface, hence no yasurime and a very smooth appearance. One factor to consider in other cases is that a sword might pass shinsa and then have its nakago damaged but not in these two examples. Hope that helps. All the best.

Dear Tobin. An honourable intention but not one which you will be able to pursue. There are no identifying marks and tracing any living family will be impossible. Add to that few families are interested in such returns. Better to do the other thing, keep it safe and eventually restore it for your family. All the best.

Dear Benjamin. You might see here for information regarding the many different oshigata available. https://www.shibuiswords.com/papers1.htm All the best.

Dear Henry. Mat has covered your question but just some thoughts on the 'daisho', there are plenty of reasons why this is so cheap. The fuchi kashira don't match, the tsuba don't match, the rest of the fittings are mediocre at best, the sageo looks suspiciously like a length of tsuka ito, the wrapping of the tsuka looks weak, the saya are pretty scruffy and plain and the wakizashi has more flaws/floors than the Empire State building. I take it that you did notice the rust, the numerous flaws in the jigane and the particularly ugly umegane? Add to this that both swords are unsigned and have no papers. The value of this set is to stick on a stand somewhere as a decorative item for a non collector. While I agree with Matt in his last remark about the blades being the deciding factor in terms of specific values between signed and unsigned blades I tend to think that the fittings do matter when it comes to a daisho, which arguably is defined by it's koshirae. Hope all this gives you some avenues for research. All the best.

Dear Bob. The Monzino collection catalogue lists this as, "An Edo shibuichi kozuka. Attributed to Kono Haruaki (1787 - 1860) Finely engraved with a fox dancing among reeds on a river bank, looking at the reflection of a woman in the water, details in two colour gold takazogan. Signed Haruaki Hogen with kao. Ex G H Naunton Collection, no. 2181 illus. pl. LXVI Ex Clement Milward collection." Sold for a hammer price of £747 against an estimate of £500-600. The Naunton describes it thus, "K., shibuichi, intaglio relievato and slight relief inlay, a fox, changing into a woman mirrors itself in a river; very fine work, the few reeds and suzuki grass chased and inlaid gold. Signed: Shummei Hogen, with flat kakihan." I don't think I have the Milward collection catalogue. All the best.

Dear Josh. Welcome to NMB. Have a look here, particularly the PDF linked in the last post by Markus. All the best.

Dear Alex. Whatever date for the blade we end up with the saya is quite a nice one and this is an example of an older sword that has been converted for use in WWII by the addition of a hanger to the saya. It's quite an attractive sword so Rule 1, don't attempt to clean anything! Doing so will drastically reduce the value. Hold on for some more comments here and perhaps add a photograph of the whole blade with the habaki removed. Looking forward to what others have to say about this one. All the best.

Dear Jo. I'm not seeing any red flags but I am struggling to see any green ones! It is very hard to make a judgement from these photographs and if they are all you have to go on then I would be cautious. What you have shown us is an unsigned and apparently shortened blade. It may be older than Edo period but that is a bit of a catch all phrase at best. It does not seem to be in very good polish and the forging seems basic. I suppose everything depends on what you want to buy and what you want to spend. This is a genuine Japanese sword and I cannot see any fatal flaws, however there might be some when you have it in hand. You don't mention koshirae or papers, I assume that it at least has a shirasaya. For whatever it is worth if I saw this blade as is I would walk away without it. Others may see something that I have missed. Hope that helps. All the best.

Tim has supplied the dimensions and the nagasa is 32.6cms so setting aside the sunobi tanto/ko wakizashi debate it's a wakizashi as described. All the best.

Lovely tsuba Curran. I'm just waiting for Chris's big reveal. All the best.

Dear Robert. Thank you for sharing these, they are indeed cute. Doves/rock pigeons are associated with Hachiman, have a look here, https://www.discover...go/miyakehachimangu/ Hence also the much reproduced Hachiman Taro tsuba of the same form. https://www.eldreds.....-inscrib_7FA4F9FAE1 An interesting example which doesn't seem to cross cultures too easily, the pigeons in our garden can scarcely waddle, never mind fly. The prospect of them having anything to do with a god of war is pretty hard to grasp. All the best.

Dear Colin. A lovely thing! Just for interest there are some fight manuals which illustrate fighting with sword and lantern, the light to blind the eyes of the opponent or at least rob them of night vision. https://elegant-weap...logspot.com/2015/09/ From memory there was a duel using such in one of the Musketeer films featuring Michael York. All the best.

Dear Jonathan, Remember? All the best.

Dear Charles. I don't think this picture format is much use to us, can you change the format and try again? All the best.

Dear Jeff. What is visible would be Hizen no Kuni ju Tada...... with a good chance that the last kanji would be yoshi though looking at the shape of the rust pit another option might be hiro for that last one. Personally I think yoshi. That is what it reads but there is quite a possibility of it being gimei. All the best.

Dear Jonathan. I am surprised that you have not had a response to this question, perhaps others have used the search feature and realised that they might be re opening a can of worms. However the simple answer is that such blades are not common, especially if you are looking for tanto, wakizashi or katana. Here's a thought, if you buy the cheap one and simply look to study it and then move it on what are you going to learn? You already know what the sugata looks like. Why not wait until one that you really want turns up? Let us know how this turns out. All the best.

Dear Sean. It is hard to tell a great deal from these pictures, however the blade appears to be signed Inshu ju Kanetsugu saku. If the blade is free from serious flaws then the price sounds about right for a wakizashi in moderate koshirae. All the best.

Dear Karatekutya. Please feel free to post your images here, lots of people willing to offer opinions for you. Look forward to seeing what you have got. All the best.

Dear Koltira. Rather say that this type of polish is currently fashionable so any blade polished recently is likely to have hadori polish, Koto, Shinto, Shinshinto. All the best.

Dear Gordon. Welcome to NMB. Well, you have your question answered but if Christian is correct and the mei or signature is shoshin, i.e. genuine then you have some choices to make. At the moment you have a wakizashi or short sword, in attractive but rather severe mounts and out of polish. You are right not to clean anything but a wipe with some light oil over both the blade and tang would be good. Option 1. It has family associations, keep it as is and lightly oil the blade from time to time. Option 2. If the bug has bitten you then some more research might lead you to want to get this restored, please note this should only be done by properly trained experts. Feel free to ask here for recommendations about how to go about this. Option 3. Pass the sword on to a collector who will do the restoration and treasure it. Before you contemplate Option 3 it would be really worth having some of our knowledgeable members have a look at the sword in hand to advise you, depends where you are in the country but I am sure that several of us would be happy to help. (I see that John, Shuguyoshi here, will be at the Birmingham Arms far this Sunday if you are in the area.) Enjoy the journey! All the best.

Dear Jonathan. I would go cautiously here. You know who he is and what he is, this blade does not seem to be a great example of his work. If you look carefully at the images you will note some fairly nasty flaws in the very narrow shinogi ji and there is something not too good about the nakago, my first guess would be that a date has been removed. For a gendai smith one might expect a very tidy nakago with some nice kesho yasurime, as you can see from the oshigata that Alexi kindly posted. The blade is essentially out of polish in in fairly unremarkable koshirae which, by definition, has to be recent. Remember that feeling when you got your Yoshimasa? I don't think you will get that with this one and by the time you have got it here it will probably cost you more. Either way let us know how it turns out. All the best.

Dear Maxime. Ubu Shinto katana, signed, fully restored and in koshirae, you did well. I would have no qualms about the mei on this one. If the tsuba is a problem you can always find another at your leisure. I can't help feeling that after someone has cared for this sword so well there is probably a paper somewhere for it. From your hints I am very sure that I do not want to know how much you had to pay for it! All the best.

As no one else has suggested this what do we think about the cartouches around the mimi representing fan paintings? All the best.

Dear Maxime. A good find, it seems to have been fully restored and in very good condition. Might we see the nakago please? All the best.