paul griff

Hello Brian,

                   100% fake….Very crude moulding to the tsuka,the detail is awful especially the wobbly join line plus the securing screw and sarute fitting is modern brass by the look…that bohi is also dreadful…..One for the scrap pile I’m afraid….

Best Regards,

                       Paul

Hello Tom,

                  I have only seen one other Gunto painted white , a first model nco with the copper hilt....That paint had also turned to ivory and appeared to be  oil based.....The sword was 100% original and I still kick myself for not buying it ! I have no doubt it was period done and probably for Manchuria...

Regards,

              Paul...

Hello,

        Stephen got it first time....modern fake ......not the worse but pretty bad !

Regards,

Paul..

Hello,

         Just picked this one up locally…..Nice dark patina to the Saya which I believe to be period….Sword had those specks of early oil based paint splashed on it when it had been mounted on a living room wall, blade was covered with a really nasty sticky grease….Sword has all the pointers of being well used i.e razor sharp with sharpening marks and plenty nicks and scars towards the kissaki and interesting repair to kuchi-gane..

Regards,

Paul..

Hello all,

              Thank’s to everyone for the information and to Dale for pointing out my error ( two feet tsuba ! )..ha,ha

Regards,

              Paul.

Hello all,

I recently acquired a tired old wakizashi because the tsuba looked interesting and would appreciate any information any members could provide i.e age ,signature etc…….The tsuba is 70mm in diameter with a blade cutout of30mm..

Regards,

Paul..

Hello Markus,

                       It’s a fake 100%.....

Regards,

              Paul..

Many thanks for that Ray,much appreciated...

Paul...

Hello,

        Appreciate a translation of the attached...

Regards,

              Paul...

Hello Stephen,

                        Crowns don’t that tightly knit and material looks very bright so will hold on to my instinct and still say reproduction.....thanks for getting me thinking again...

Regards,

              Paul...

Hello,

         As Bruce points out ,tassel is a reproduction and saya looks to be have been repainted but still a very nice sword..

Regards,

             Paul.

Hello Stephen,

                        Without seeing the crowns I would say a very well made silk reproduction.....Only my opinion and not a tassel expert just a collector..

Regards,

             Paul...

Hello Geoff,

                   As Chris pointed out it’s a fake...100%...all of it is fake !

Regards,

                Paul..

Hello Tony,

                  Good luck...Unprofessional and ignorant fools have infiltrated the system everywhere and as Stephen highlighted the two police officers are the epitome of unprofessionalism...

Regards,

               Paul...

Hello Erwin,

                   Well done,Very nice all round package and good photo’s....

Regards,

              Paul..

Hello,

         Yes,thanks for sharing.....Can’t expect to get paperwork with all war trophies...most have mine have oral history from veterans family etc.........Quality package like that from respected dealer...good enough for me...

Regards,

              Paul...

Hello Bruce,

                    I remember this topic from the past......I talked to a veteran many years ago who painted his nco gunto silver ,luckily his son managed to get off with acetone without damaging the remaining paint...I know have the sword......also, many years ago I turned down a white painted copper hilt nco only to find out it was 100% and probably painted for winter use...

Regards,

              Paul.

Hello JP,

              Best Regards to you ,your family and pets....keep going ,seldom are things easy that are worthwhile but you will get there...

kind Regards,

                       Paul....

Hello Nigel,

                   As above ,reproduction 100%.... Type in  on a search engine - WW2 Japanese Officers sword for sale and you will find a photograph of a similar sword ,copy it and send it to the auction house  with these reports and it should be enough.....If not ,report them to their governing body or local trade description officer.....Be careful not to damage ,alter or clean the sword...Best if it is returned untouched in original package.... if possible ? ......If you alter or damage it you are stuck with it ! Good luck..

Best Regards,

                      Paul..

Hello Bruce,

                    Thank you,.....altering it now....Knot is a replacement  I have had for years but very good quality....nearly all the nco knots I come across are really fragile so I just use this one for effect.

Regards,

              Paul..

Hello,

         A couple more of the hilt and with a knot for my new “best friend”....

Regards,

              Paul..

Hello,

          Thank you for the information and comments....Some more photo’s attached and if anyone needs more just let me know..

                 Regards,

                                Paul..

Hello,

          Yes,you could be right there ? Tsuka does have slight distortion to the rear and the blade shows noticeable use on the first 8 ins or so.....

Regards,

               Paul...

Hello and thank you for the comments,

        Nice to share information and hopefully prevent someone being “tucked up “ especially with the increased value . Some interesting points about the first model include for instance the hanging rings are 3.5 mm compared to the later 4.5 mm which may be a good indication the sword never revisited the arsenal  or workshop for update or repair....Also the tsuka has a pronounced “ kick” to it reminiscent of ancient tachi , a feature that does not seem to appear on first models..

Regards,

               Paul..

Hello,

         Picked this one up recently and maybe of interest to someone interested in the serial numbers....Sword has not been on the market and was on the wall of an old gents house then subject to house clearance and for the last twenty five years in a wardrobe...Interestingly the blade and saya numbers are only out by twenty so would hazard a guess they left the arsenal together....Lovely overall patina with wear around the saya where a hand has gripped and distortion to the hanging ring where the sword has been suspended..

Regards,

               Paul...